Filter

    Shop hundreds of Halloween party supplies and decorations, all designed in-house at My Mind's Eye. Browse by theme like Vintage Halloween, Haunted Village, and Ghoul Gang, or start with our story Halloween Decorating Ideas for Every Room in the House.

    510 products
    NEW
    Halloween Sketchy Stars Plate
    Halloween Sketchy Stars Plate
    $ 8.49
    BESTSELLER
    Vintage Halloween Characters Plate
    Vintage Halloween Characters Plate
    $ 8.49
    NEW
    Fall Marigold 8" Plate
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Black Fall Plaid Dinner Napkin
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Halloween Toile 9 inch Plate
    Halloween Toile 9" Plate
    $ 7.99
    BESTSELLER
    Halloween Scenes 9" Plate Set (9 plates)
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Halloween Toile Dinner Napkin
    Halloween Toile Dinner Napkin
    Halloween Toile Dinner Napkin
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Toile Striped Dinner Napkin
    Toile Striped Dinner Napkin
    Toile Striped Dinner Napkin
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Bewitching 9" Plate Set
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Witch Hat 10 inch Plate
    Witch Hat 10" Plate
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Welcome Witches Dinner Napkin Set
    Welcome Witches Dinner Napkin Set
    $ 7.99
    BESTSELLER
    Spooky Cat Paper Plate 9 inch
    Shakira holding up the Spooky Cat Paper Plate, a black cat head shaped plate with holographic foil accents
    Spooky Cat Paper Plate - 9"
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Spooky Friends Paper Plates 9 inch
    Shakira lifting a Spooky Friends Paper Plate with black scalloped edges over her Halloween basket
    Spooky Friends Paper Plates - 9"
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Spooky Ghost Napkin
    Shakira placing a Spooky Ghost Napkin into her Halloween basket
    Spooky Ghost Napkin
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Booquette Spooky Things 9 inch Plate
    Booquette Spooky Things 9" Plate
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Booquette Ghosts 8 inch Plate
    Booquette Ghosts 8" Plate
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Booquette Ghost Shaped Plate
    Booquette Ghost Shaped Plate
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Follow the Moonlight 8 inch Plate
    Follow the Moonlight 8" Plate
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Boo & Spooky Plate Set 9"
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Pumpkin Plate
    Pumpkin Plate
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Spooky Icons 9 inch Plate
    Spooky Icons 9" Plate
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Witch Hat Napkin
    Witch Hat Napkin
    Witch Hat Napkin
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Spooky House Napkin
    Spooky House Napkin
    Spooky House Napkin
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Bow Pumpkin Plate
    Bow Pumpkin Plate
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Spooky Icon 8" Plate Set
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Black and Cream Striped Dinner Napkin
    Black and Cream Striped Dinner Napkin
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Orange Polka Dot Cello Treat Bags with Pumpkin Tags
    Orange Polka Dot Cello Treat Bags with Pumpkin Tags
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Vintage Witchy Cat Plate
    Vintage Witchy Cat Plate
    $ 7.99