Filter

    Shop hundreds of Halloween party supplies and decorations, all designed in-house at My Mind's Eye. Browse by theme like Vintage Halloween, Haunted Village, and Ghoul Gang, or start with our story Halloween Decorating Ideas for Every Room in the House.

    506 products
    29% OFF
    Striped Cocktail Napkin Set
    $ 6.99 $ 4.99 Save $ 2.00
    Good Witch Bad Witch Cocktail Napkin Set
    $ 6.99
    29% OFF
    Vintage Trick or Treat Cocktail Napkin
    $ 6.99 $ 4.99 Save $ 2.00
    Sold Out
    Vintage Boo Cocktail Napkin
    $ 6.99
    80% OFF
    Vintage Pumpkin Paper Bowls
    $ 6.99 $ 1.39 Save $ 5.60
    50% OFF
    Cool Ghosts Paper Cocktail Napkin
    $ 6.99 $ 3.49 Save $ 3.50
    50% OFF
    Scallop Halloween Icons Paper Cocktail Napkin
    $ 6.99 $ 3.49 Save $ 3.50
    50% OFF
    Halloween Checkerboard Scallop Paper Cocktail Napkin
    $ 6.99 $ 3.49 Save $ 3.50
    50% OFF
    I Put A Spell On You Paper Cocktail Napkin
    $ 6.99 $ 3.49 Save $ 3.50
    50% OFF
    Icons Scallop Paper Cocktail Napkin
    $ 6.99 $ 3.49 Save $ 3.50
    50% OFF
    Black and Gold Star Paper Napkin
    $ 6.99 $ 3.49 Save $ 3.50
    50% OFF
    Trick or Treat Paper Napkin
    $ 6.99 $ 3.49 Save $ 3.50
    50% OFF
    Made Me Boo Paper Cocktail Napkin
    $ 6.99 $ 3.49 Save $ 3.50
    80% OFF
    Witch Icons Fringed Paper Cocktail Napkin
    $ 6.99 $ 1.39 Save $ 5.60
    50% OFF
    Mystical Paper Cocktail Napkin Set
    $ 6.99 $ 3.49 Save $ 3.50
    50% OFF
    Witching Hour Broom Shaped Paper Dinner Napkin
    $ 6.99 $ 3.49 Save $ 3.50
    50% OFF
    Vintage Bat Paper Cocktail Napkin
    $ 6.99 $ 3.49 Save $ 3.50
    50% OFF
    Freakin' Bats Let's Hang Paper Cocktail Napkin
    $ 6.99 $ 3.49 Save $ 3.50
    50% OFF
    Salem Apothecary Rat Cocktail Napkins
    $ 6.99 $ 3.49 Save $ 3.50
    Sold Out
    Trick or Treat Bamboo Reusable Tray
    $ 15.99 $ 6.99 Save $ 9.00
    50% OFF
    Orange Ghosts To Go Boxes
    $ 11.99 $ 5.99 Save $ 6.00
    20% OFF
    Happy Halloween Halloween Paper Plate
    $ 7.99 $ 6.39 Save $ 1.60
    NEW
    Happy Halloween Paper Cup
    Happy Halloween Paper Cup
    $ 5.99
    NEW
    Vintage Stars Halloween Party Cup
    Vintage Stars Halloween Party Cup
    $ 5.99
    50% OFF
    Halloween Coloring Activity Placemat
    $ 9.99 $ 4.99 Save $ 5.00
    40% OFF
    Halloween Old Maid Card Game
    $ 5.99 $ 3.59 Save $ 2.40
    40% OFF
    Build a Haunted House
    $ 5.99 $ 3.59 Save $ 2.40
    40% OFF
    Halloween Countdown Paper Chain
    $ 5.99 $ 3.59 Save $ 2.40

    Showing 448 of 506 products

    Load more