Filter

    Shop hundreds of Halloween party supplies and decorations, all designed in-house at My Mind's Eye. Browse by theme like Vintage Halloween, Haunted Village, and Ghoul Gang, or start with our story Halloween Decorating Ideas for Every Room in the House.

    480 products
    Sold Out
    Witching Hour Witch Hat Banner
    $ 14.99
    NEW
    Moonlight Puzzle
    Moonlight Puzzle - 311 pieces (round)
    $ 13.99
    Spooky House Jigsaw Puzzle 300 pc
    $ 13.99
    35%+ OFF
    Groovy Pumpkin Party Cup
    $ 13.99 $ 8.99 Save $ 5.00
    35%+ OFF
    Pumpkin Treat Box Set
    $ 13.99 $ 8.99 Save $ 5.00
    29% OFF
    Occasions Ghost Treat Boxes
    $ 13.99 $ 9.99 Save $ 4.00
    29% OFF
    Halloween Coffin Treat Boxes, Set of 8
    $ 13.99 $ 9.99 Save $ 4.00
    Sold Out
    Haunted House Jigsaw Puzzle 300 pcs
    $ 13.99
    35%+ OFF
    Halloween Icons Jigsaw Puzzle 300 pcs
    $ 13.99 $ 8.99 Save $ 5.00
    30% OFF
    Canvas and Felt Halloween Tic-Tac-Toe Game
    $ 19.99 $ 13.99 Save $ 6.00
    Sold Out
    Vintage Halloween Pumpkin Puzzle 295 pcs
    $ 13.99 $ 9.99 Save $ 4.00
    35%+ OFF
    Ghoul Gang Puzzle 193 pcs
    $ 13.99 $ 8.99 Save $ 5.00
    35%+ OFF
    Spellbound Owl and Lightning Banner Set
    $ 13.99 $ 8.99 Save $ 5.00
    35%+ OFF
    JUMBO Foiled Scattered Pumpkins 8 oz Baking Cups
    $ 13.50 $ 7.99 Save $ 5.51
    35%+ OFF
    JUMBO Foil Pumpkin Disco 8 oz Baking Cups (40 ct - 8oz)
    $ 13.50 $ 7.99 Save $ 5.51
    35%+ OFF
    JUMBO Foil Groovy Ghosts 8 oz Baking Cups (40 ct - 8oz)
    $ 13.50 $ 7.99 Save $ 5.51
    35%+ OFF
    JUMBO Party More Food Cups (40 pcs)
    $ 13.50 $ 7.99 Save $ 5.51
    NEW
    Haunted House Gable Boxes
    $ 12.99
    NEW
    Witch Hat Treat Holders
    Witch Hat Treat Holders
    Witch Hat Treat Holders
    $ 12.99
    31% OFF
    Haunted House Halloween Gable Treat Boxes
    $ 12.99 $ 8.99 Save $ 4.00
    BESTSELLER
    Halloween Village Treat Boxes
    $ 12.99
    35%+ OFF
    Spellbound Castle Treat Boxes
    $ 12.99 $ 7.99 Save $ 5.00
    Sold Out
    Vampire 348 pc Shaped Jigsaw Puzzle
    $ 12.99
    Sold Out
    Trick or Treat Dogs 300 pc Shaped Jigsaw Puzzle
    $ 12.99
    35%+ OFF
    Fresh Bat Wings 300 pc Shaped Jigsaw Puzzle
    $ 12.99 $ 7.99 Save $ 5.00
    35%+ OFF
    Frankenstein 317 pc Shaped Jigsaw Puzzle
    $ 12.99 $ 7.99 Save $ 5.00
    31% OFF
    Occasions By Shakira - Spooky Sweets Ghost Treat Boxes
    $ 12.99 $ 8.99 Save $ 4.00
    31% OFF
    Frank & Mummy Coffin Treat Boxes
    $ 12.99 $ 8.99 Save $ 4.00