Filter

    Shop hundreds of Halloween party supplies and decorations, all designed in-house at My Mind's Eye. Browse by theme like Vintage Halloween, Haunted Village, and Ghoul Gang, or start with our story Halloween Decorating Ideas for Every Room in the House.

    All New HalloweenComplete HalloweenCustomer FavoritesShop by Theme
    512 products
    NEW
    Vintage Ric Rac and Stars Reusable Straws
    Vintage Ric Rac and Stars Reuseable Straws
    $ 8.99
    NEW
    Orange Black and Cream Sewn Crepe Festoon
    $ 8.99
    45% OFF
    Bow Ghosts Reusable Straws
    $ 8.99 $ 4.94 Save $ 4.05
    45% OFF
    Ghosts and Jacks Reusable Straws
    $ 8.99 $ 4.94 Save $ 4.05
    44% OFF
    Pink & Orange Checkered 11" Paper Plate
    $ 8.99 $ 4.99 Save $ 4.00
    Green Stripe Pink Stripe 11" Plate Set
    $ 8.99
    33% OFF
    Vintage Harlequin 11" Plate
    $ 8.99 $ 5.99 Save $ 3.00
    45% OFF
    Ghosts and Checks Reusable Straws
    $ 8.99 $ 4.94 Save $ 4.05
    80% OFF
    Spooky Sketches Snake Handle Party Cups
    $ 8.99 $ 1.79 Save $ 7.20
    80% OFF
    A Little Ghoul Pink Ghost Paper Party Cup - Occasions by Shakira
    $ 8.99 $ 1.79 Save $ 7.20
    45% OFF
    Pink/Orange Pumpkins Reusable Straws
    $ 8.99 $ 4.94 Save $ 4.05
    45% OFF
    Occasions By Shakira - Spooky Sweets Reusable Straws
    $ 8.99 $ 4.94 Save $ 4.05
    Black Bracket Edge Paper Plate
    $ 8.50
    Falloween Rust Scalloped Round 10" Paper Plate
    $ 8.50
    Occasions Boo Ghost Scatter 10" Paper Plate
    $ 8.50
    30% OFF
    Orange and Black Striped 10" Paper Plate Set
    $ 8.50 $ 5.99 Save $ 2.51
    NEW
    Black Fall Plaid 10" Plate
    $ 8.49
    NEW
    Cream Pumpkin Shaped Plate
    $ 8.49
    NEW
    Fall Flora 9" Plate
    $ 8.49
    NEW
    Black Gingham 10 inch Plate
    Black Gingham 10" Plate
    $ 8.49
    NEW
    Moonlight Moths 10" Plate Set
    $ 8.49
    NEW
    Black and Cream Stripes Scalloped 10 inch Plate
    Black and Cream Stripes Scalloped 10" Plate
    $ 8.49
    NEW
    Happy Halloween 10 inch Plate
    Happy Halloween 10" Plate
    $ 8.49
    NEW
    Halloween Sketchy Stars Plate
    Halloween Sketchy Stars Plate
    $ 8.49
    BESTSELLER
    Vintage Halloween Characters Plate
    Vintage Halloween Characters Plate
    $ 8.49
    NEW
    Fall Marigold 8" Plate
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Black Fall Plaid Dinner Napkin
    $ 7.99
    NEW
    Halloween Toile 9 inch Plate
    Halloween Toile 9" Plate
    $ 7.99

    Showing 168 of 512 products

    Load more