Our Halloween Paper Party Supplies for 2024 are now available! Shop eerie decorations and spooky tabletop for a hauntingly good time.  Shop all party themes here.


363 products
Sale
Hey Pumpkin Felt Pennant Banner
$ 9.99 $ 7.99 Save $ 2.00
Sale
Hey Pumpkin Pumpkin Paper Party Cups
$ 5.99 $ 4.79 Save $ 1.20
Sale
Ghost Puffy Felt Banner
$ 19.99 $ 11.99 Save $ 8.00
Sale
Boo Ghosts Paper Cocktail Napkin
$ 6.99 $ 3.99 Save $ 3.00
Sale
Vintage Halloween Bag of Bats
$ 9.99 $ 7.99 Save $ 2.00
Sale
Happy Haunting Iridescent Mini Banner Set
$ 15.99 $ 7.99 Save $ 8.00
Sale
Vintage Halloween 8" Cat Plate - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods
Vintage Halloween 8
Vintage Halloween 8" Cat Paper Plates
$ 7.99 $ 3.99 Save $ 4.00
Sale
Halloween Characters Paper Plate
$ 7.99 $ 4.99 Save $ 3.00
Realistic Moon Plate
$ 7.99
White and Black Coffin Tombstone Treat Boxes
$ 12.99
Vintage Cat Shaped Mylar Balloon
$ 9.99
Sale
Jack-o-Lantern Canvas Trick or Treat Bag
$ 9.99 $ 4.99 Save $ 5.00
Sold Out
Boo Yah! Felt Pennant Banner
$ 9.99 $ 6.99 Save $ 3.00
Sale
Vintage Halloween Boo Cozy To-Go Cup-8ct
$ 10.99 $ 5.50 Save $ 5.49
Sale
Vintage Halloween Boo Mylar Balloon
$ 9.99 $ 4.99 Save $ 5.00
Sale
Trick or Treat Party Cups
$ 5.99 $ 2.99 Save $ 3.00
Sale
Pink Pumpkin Shaped 7" Paper Plates
$ 7.99 $ 3.99 Save $ 4.00
Sale
Happy Haunting Party Fans 6 set
$ 24.99 $ 12.50 Save $ 12.49
Sale
Vintage Halloween Spooky Banner - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods
Vintage Halloween Spooky Banner - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods
Vintage Halloween Spooky Banner
$ 9.99 $ 4.99 Save $ 5.00
A Little Ghoul Pumpkin Shaped Paper Napkin Set - Occasions by Shakira
$ 7.99
Sale
Holographic Stars and Moon Food Cups (36 pcs)
$ 6.99 $ 3.50 Save $ 3.49
Sale
Long Ghost Shaped Paper Dinner Napkin
$ 7.99 $ 3.99 Save $ 4.00
Sale
Hey Pumpkin Pink Witch Shaped Paper Plate
$ 7.99 $ 6.39 Save $ 1.60
Sale
Vintage Halloween Pumpkin Cocktail Napkin Set
$ 6.99 $ 5.49 Save $ 1.50
Sale
Ghoul Gang Checkered Paper Plate
$ 7.99 $ 6.39 Save $ 1.60
Sale
Trick or Treat Canvas Banner
$ 14.99 $ 7.50 Save $ 7.49
Sale
Happy Haunting Boo Napkins
$ 7.99 $ 3.99 Save $ 4.00
Sale
Trick or Treat Treat Bags
$ 8.99 $ 4.99 Save $ 4.00