Skip to content

EASTER / SPRING
NEW GRADUATION
HOLIDAYS
BIRTHDAYS
SPORTS THEMES
MILESTONES
TRENDING
PAPER PARTY SUPPLIES
Log in

Instagram
Facebook
YouTube
Pinterest

Cart

Rush Handling Fee $ 10.00

Learn More

Almost there, add $100.00 more to get FREE SHIPPING!

Subtotal

$ 0.00

Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.

Your cart is currently empty.

Instagram
Facebook
YouTube
Pinterest

Log in Search Cart

EASTER / SPRING
NEW GRADUATION
HOLIDAYS
BIRTHDAYS
SPORTS THEMES
MILESTONES
TRENDING
PAPER PARTY SUPPLIES

Search "Close (esc)"

Home /

VALENTINE'S DAY TABLETOP & DECOR

Filter

Balloon (2)
Bamboo Tray (2)
Banner (9)
Banners (3)
Cake Topper (2)
cup (3)
Cup (1)
Fans (1)
Food Cups (10)
game (1)
Gift Bag (4)
Hanging Décor (3)
Napkin (28)
Napkins (3)
Party Fans (1)
Photo Props (1)
Plate (24)
plate (6)
Plates (4)
Project Kit (4)
Puzzle (1)
socks (2)
Straws (1)
Table Runner (1)
Table Runners (4)
to go cups (11)
Treat Bags (2)
Treat Box (5)

In stock (121)
Out of stock (19)

Buy 5 get 25% off beautiful Valentine's plates, napkins, party fans, banners, and more in lovely pink, red, white, and cream hues for an unforgettable Valentine's Day celebration.

139 products

Sort

Valentine's Baking/Treat Cups - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Valentine's Baking/Treat Cups

Blush Scalloped 9" Plates - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Blush Scalloped 9

Blush Scalloped 9" Paper Plates

Checkered Heart Shaped Tray

Pink with Red Dots Paper Table Runner

Heart 7" Plate - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Heart 7" Paper Plates

Valentine Truck Shaped Plate

Valentines Photo Props - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Valentines Photo Props - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Valentines Photo Props

XO Shaped Paper Plates

Valentine Red Striped Scalloped Plate

Valentine Pink Stripe Scallop Cocktail Napkin

Valentine's Cupcake Kit - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Valentine's Cupcake Kit - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Valentine's Cupcake Kit

Valentine Hearts Paper Cup

Valentine Lips Shaped Napkins

Valentine Red Scattered Heart Scalloped 8" Plate

XOXO Glitter Banner Set

Sold Out

XOXO Felt Pennant

Occasions By Shakira - Valentine Pennant Flags

Valentine Love Note Shaped Napkin

Checkered Heart Shaped Paper Plate

Heart You Paper Fan Set

Envelope Treat Boxes

Love You More Treat Bags

Blush Striped Cocktail Napkins - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Blush Striped Cocktail Napkins

Valentines Mini Banner Set - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Valentines Mini Banner Set - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Valentines Mini Banner Set

Secret Admirer Honeycomb Hanging Hearts

Classic Easter On Sale

Classic Easter favorites—now at 25% off. From elegant tableware to charming décor, these timeless pieces won’t last long. Shop before they’re gone!

EASTER DECOR ON SALE

SIGNATURE EASTER 2025

Our new Signature Easter line is here! Featuring elegant designs, festive décor, and charming details, this collection is perfect for celebrating in style. We're so excited, this is our cutest Easter ever!

NEW 2025 EASTER & SPRING

GRADUATION CELEBRATION

Whether it’s classic black or school colors, this is the year to celebrate your graduate in style. Choose from a wide variety of beautiful tabletop and décor to make the day unforgettable!

SHOP GRADUATION

ABOUT/CONTACT

About us
Contact us
Privacy | Terms | Policies
Wholesale
Would you like to work with us?

Follow us on INSTAGRAM

Click here

SHIPPING QUESTIONS

Delivery Estimate

WHOLESALE INFO

Click here

PARTY BY EMAIL

What surprises await? 🧐 Get exclusive deals, secret offers, and insider perks—only in our weekly newsletter. Subscribe now! 🚀

Enter your email Subscribe

Instagram
Facebook
YouTube
Pinterest

© 2025 My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Valentine's Day 2024 Party Supplies - Plates & Napkins | My Mind's Eye

★ Reviews

Let customers speak for us

92%

(2620)

4%

(115)

2%

(56)

1%

(16)

1%

(42)

J

Bunny Treat Box

Johanna

Cute design/not worth the price

Super cute bunny design, but I was disappointed that they didn’t close at the top like actual boxes. They were extremely easy to pop open and seem sturdy. These are more like bags NOT boxes. Also, one of the bags came without handles. For the price, I expected a bit more.

K

Foil Mint Gingham Floral Baking Cup

Karen

Perfect for Birthday cupcakes

We were celebrating a birthday and these cups were the perfect answer to party. No need for forks as the paper cups peel off of the cupcakes with ease. They looked cheerful and springy. We used the green check and the Lemon backing cups. I would definitely by this again

J

Vintage Easter Paper Plate

Jan Foley

They are so cute

R

Bright Birthday Bunting Banner

Rosalind Adams

Beautiful garland!

5 stars ⭐️

G

JUMBO Lavendar Lots of Hearts 8 oz Baking Cups (40 ct)

Gabrielle

Cups great, shipping not

I love your cups, they are perfect for my biz. I just wish you shipped through Amazon because UPS charged me hundreds, a gross amount, and the shipping was as much as the cups. If you can offer via amazon I will buy again.

1 2 3