Our best-selling Christmas party supplies, ranked by what customers actually bought last season. These are the original designs from our in-house studio that people came back for again and again, from village houses and gingerbread to plaid plates, felt banners, cookie boxes, tinsel and puzzles, gathered in one place so you can start with the proven favorites.
Light-up Haunted House
A My Mind's Eye Halloween village is built one paper house at a time, each one heavyweight paperboard with a battery powered light tucked inside so the windows glow once the room goes dark.
Football is Back!
From sports, first birthdays to forever-after, find the plates, napkins, and décor that make every gathering feel effortlessly special. Pick any 5 pieces across our sports, birthday, baby, wedding, and everyday collections and get 25% off! Code: buy5save25
Halloween Sale
Welcome to the My Mind's Eye Halloween sale, where favorite designs from past seasons get one more chance to haunt your party table. Shop shaped plates, napkins, felt banners, treat boxes, games, puzzles, and more, all original designs from our studio. Once they're gone, they're gone for good!