Skip to content

VALENTINES
AFTER CHRISTMAS SALE
NEW & TRENDING
HOLIDAY
BIRTHDAY
EVERYDAY
PAPER PARTY SUPPLIES
Log in

Instagram
Facebook
YouTube
Pinterest

Cart

Rush Handling Fee $ 10.00

Learn More

Almost there, add $100.00 more to get FREE SHIPPING!

Subtotal

$ 0.00

Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.

Your cart is currently empty.

Instagram
Facebook
YouTube
Pinterest

Log in Search Cart

VALENTINES
AFTER CHRISTMAS SALE
NEW & TRENDING
HOLIDAY

TRENDING NOW
After Christmas Sale
50% Off Christmas Themes
Valentines Drop
Valentine Faves at 25% Off
COMING SOON
Valentines Day
St. Patrick's Day
Lunar New Year
SAVE THE DATE
Easter
Mother's Day
Cinco De Mayo
WINTER | SPRING
Valentine's Day
Lunar New Year
St. Patrick's Day
Easter
Cinco De Mayo
Mother's Day
Hanukkah
Christmas
New Year's Eve
SUMMER | FALL
Graduation
Memorial Day
Father's Day
Fourth of July
Back To School
Diwali
Halloween
Thanksgiving | Harvest
BIRTHDAY

GIRL
Under the Sea
CowGal
Princess
Unicorn
Royal Princess
Tea Party
Disco Party
Mermaid
CowGirl
Adventure
BOY
Cowboy
Construction
Howdy Partner
Blast Off
Video Game
Adventure
NEUTRAL
Adventure
Carnival
Pet Party
Spellbound
Safari
COLOR FUN
Bright Birthday
Pretty Pastels
Oui Party
Confetti Party
Make a Wish
Cake By Courtney
SPORTS
Football Party
Basketball Party
Baseball Party
Soccer Party
Golf Party
Pickleball Party
Tennis Party
Racecar Party
EVERYDAY

NEW & TRENDING
Pretty Pastel Party
Baby Blue
Baby Pink
Baby Neutral
New Fruit Collections
Strawberry
Orange
Lemon
MILESTONES
Bachelorette / Bride to Be
Bridal Shower
Wedding
Tying The Knot Collection
Baby Shower - Neutral
Baby Shower Blue
Baby Shower Pink
Baby Shower Fruit
Baby Shower Strawberry
Baby Shower Orange
Baby Shower Lemon
First Birthday Neutrals & Pastels
First Birthday Fruit Themes
Back to School
Graduation
SPORTS THEMES
Football
Basketball
Baseball
Soccer
Golf
Pickleball
Tennis
Racing
SUMMER / SPRING
Color Basics | Pastels
Fruit Party Themes
Strawberry
Lemon
Orange
BACK TO SCHOOL
Back to School Complete Collection
Back to School Teacher Gifts
Back to School Breakfast
PAPER PARTY SUPPLIES

Search "Close (esc)"

Home /

Valentine's Day Classics & Favorites

Filter

baking cups (13)
balloons and mylar (2)
bamboo (2)
banners (21)
cake toppers (3)
fans (2)
games (1)
gift bags (4)
kids crafts (6)
kits (6)
napkins (62)
photo props (1)
plate (65)
puzzles (1)
socks (2)
straws (1)
table runners & cloth (7)
to-go cups (21)
trays / platters (2)
treat boxes & favors (12)

This collections includes popular Valentine's Day favorites from years past. Get 25% off all Classic Valentine items with code: VAL25

234 products

Sort

Gingham Heart Shaped Tray

Pink with Red Dots Paper Table Runner

Sale

Heart You Honeycomb Hanging Hearts

Regular price $ 11.99 Sale price$ 4.99 Save $ 7.00

Valentine Truck Shaped Plate

Valentine Pink Stripe Scallop Cocktail Napkin

XO Shaped Paper Plates

XOXO Glitter Banner Set

Heart You Paper Fan Set

Valentine Lips Shaped Napkins

Secret Admirer Honeycomb Hanging Hearts

Strawberry Shaped Paper Plate

Checkered Heart Shaped Paper Plate

Ripple Edge Dinner Napkin

Blush Scalloped 9" Plates - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Blush Scalloped 9

Blush Scalloped 9" Paper Plates

Sale

Pink and Red Checked Paper Plates

Regular price $ 7.99 Sale price$ 6.39 Save $ 1.60

Heart 7" Plate - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Heart 7" Paper Plates

Valentine Red Striped Scalloped Plate

Striped Fringe Guest Towel Dinner Napkin

Sale

Valentines Photo Props - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Valentines Photo Props - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Valentines Photo Props

Regular price $ 14.99 Sale price$ 3.75 Save $ 11.24

Sale

Valentine's Cupcake Kit - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Valentine's Cupcake Kit - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Valentine's Cupcake Kit

Regular price $ 12.99 Sale price$ 3.25 Save $ 9.74

Sale

Red and Pink Checked Fringed Paper Dinner Napkins

Regular price $ 7.99 Sale price$ 6.39 Save $ 1.60

Pembroke Pink Floral 10" Plate

Pembroke Paper Dinner Napkin

Valentine Hearts Paper Cup

Valentine Red Scattered Heart Scalloped 8" Plate

Envelope Treat Boxes

NEW VALENTINE's DAY COLLECTION

Our sweetest Valentine's Day Collection ever with 8 new themes you will love!

Cute teddy bears and playful heart details

Cute teddy bears and playful heart details

Playful charm-bracelet motifs, soft reds, pinks & creams.

Playful charm-bracelet motifs, soft reds, pinks & creams.

Soft hued hearts, vintage-inspired designs deliver timeless celebrations

Soft hued hearts, vintage-inspired designs deliver timeless celebrations

Sweet cherries, gingham checks, & soft vintage style patterns

Sweet cherries, gingham checks, & soft vintage style patterns

Playful ribbons, soft pastels, & delicate bow details

Playful ribbons, soft pastels, & delicate bow details

Set the scene for a flirty, casino-inspired Galentine’s bash

Set the scene for a flirty, casino-inspired Galentine’s bash

Classic black and creamy white tones with bold hearts

Classic black and creamy white tones with bold hearts

Best Selling: Valentine's Village with the cutest little pink houses

Best Selling: Valentine's Village with the cutest little pink houses

Scattered hearts, XOXO banners, lips, & bold pops of pink

Scattered hearts, XOXO banners, lips, & bold pops of pink

Trending: Valentines Day Charm Kit with enough for 3

Trending: Valentines Day Charm Kit with enough for 3

Shop Classic Valentine Faves at 25% Off

Shop Classic Valentine Faves at 25% Off

Cute teddy bears and playful heart details

Cute teddy bears and playful heart details

Playful charm-bracelet motifs, soft reds, pinks & creams.

Playful charm-bracelet motifs, soft reds, pinks & creams.

Soft hued hearts, vintage-inspired designs deliver timeless celebrations

Soft hued hearts, vintage-inspired designs deliver timeless celebrations

Sweet cherries, gingham checks, & soft vintage style patterns

Sweet cherries, gingham checks, & soft vintage style patterns

Playful ribbons, soft pastels, & delicate bow details

Playful ribbons, soft pastels, & delicate bow details

Set the scene for a flirty, casino-inspired Galentine’s bash

Set the scene for a flirty, casino-inspired Galentine’s bash

Classic black and creamy white tones with bold hearts

Classic black and creamy white tones with bold hearts

Best Selling: Valentine's Village with the cutest little pink houses

Best Selling: Valentine's Village with the cutest little pink houses

Scattered hearts, XOXO banners, lips, & bold pops of pink

Scattered hearts, XOXO banners, lips, & bold pops of pink

Trending: Valentines Day Charm Kit with enough for 3

Trending: Valentines Day Charm Kit with enough for 3

Shop Classic Valentine Faves at 25% Off

Shop Classic Valentine Faves at 25% Off

Charm Bracelet Kit

Get ready to spread the love with this Valentine's Day Charm Bracelet Kit! Perfect for crafting parties, sleepovers, or solo creative sessions, this kit includes everything needed to design personalized bracelets bursting with charm.

Shop Charm Bracelet Party

Valentine's Village

Our adorable light-up Valentine’s village houses bring instant Valentine’s charm to any display. Sure to delight, these collectible pieces are perfect for gifting and décor.

Valentine's Village Houses

CLassic Black & White

Get ready to make hearts flutter! These stunning black and white honeycomb hanging hearts bring charm to any Valentine's Day celebration. The beautiful contrast creates eye-catching dimension that works beautifully as party décor, window displays, or festive backdrops.

SHOP BLACK & WHITE

ABOUT/CONTACT

About My Mind's Eye
Customer Care & Support
Shipping Q & A
Privacy | Terms | Policies
Would you like to work with us?

Follow us on INSTAGRAM

CLICK HERE

MME CUSTOMER CARE & SUPPORT

CLICK HERE

WHOLESALE SIGN UP INFORMATION

CLICK HERE

PARTY BY EMAIL

What surprises await? 🧐 Get exclusive deals, secret offers, and insider perks—only in our weekly newsletter. Subscribe now! 🚀

Enter your email Subscribe

Instagram
Facebook
YouTube
Pinterest

© 2026 My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Valentine's Day Classics & Favorites

★ Reviews

Let customers speak for us

92%

(3319)

4%

(146)

2%

(67)

1%

(25)

2%

(58)

S

Gingerbread Tall House Dinner Napkin

Susan Overgaard

Gingerbread House fun

Fun style. A little smaller than I’d prefer, but will work just fine for our theme.

T

Green Bow Ric Rac Cookie Box

Tina Nixon

Great for cookies

I used the cute boxes to send guest home with a sweet treat on New Year’s Eve. I loved them and so did my guests.

C

Occasions by Shakira - Storybook Shaped Plate

Celeste Ureña

Enchanting Theme

My sons first birthday was Christmas Storybook. It was hard to find ANYTHING to go with my made up theme until I found the plates and cups from this collection! These were a hit!

C

Christmas Memories Kraft Cookie Boxes

Celeste Ureña

Sturdy & Super Cute

I loved handing these out to my guests! We had these for the treats table at my sons Christmas themed first birthday.

C

Elves' Workshop

Chrissy W.

Beautiful Christmas Village houses

These are exactly like they look online. Such sweet details! I also love how they light up.

1 2 3