Rush Handling Fee $ 10.00

Learn More

Almost there, add $100.00 more to get FREE SHIPPING!

Your cart is currently empty.

50% Baking Cups Collection

Discover our 50% Baking Collection, featuring a variety of baking cups and treat cups adorned with festive designs. Perfect for holiday baking and gifting, these items add a special touch to your seasonal creations.

70 products

Sort

Foiled JUMBO Bows/Icons 8 oz Baking Cups (40 ct)

JUMBO Red Cream Bows 8 oz Baking Cups (40 ct)

Foiled JUMBO Gingerbread Snowflakes Jumbo Food Cups (40 pcs)

Foiled JUMBO Holly Bows 8 oz Baking Cups (40 ct)

Gingerbread Candy Swirls 5 oz Baking Cups

Gold Foil Bows on Pink 5 oz Baking Cups

Gold Foil Bows/Icons on Pink 5 oz Baking Cups

Gold Foil Gingerbread Man 5 oz Baking Cups

Gold Foil Nutcracker Shaped 5 oz Baking Cups

Sold Out

Gold Foil Santa with Christmas Trees 5 oz Baking Cups

Gold Foil Star Floral and Stripe 5 oz Baking Cups

Gold Foil Trees and Stars 5 oz Baking Cups

Gold Foil Pink Bows Baking Cups (50 - 5 oz)

Pink Gingerbread House 5 oz Baking Cups

Red Bow Loaf Pan Set

Red Foil Candy Stripes 5 oz Baking Cups

Truck Plaid Baking/Treat Cups - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Truck Plaid Baking/Treat Cups - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Truck Plaid Baking/Treat Cups

Sale

Gather Wreath Baking/Treat Cups - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Gather Wreath Baking/Treat Cups - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Gather Wreath Baking/Treat Cups

$ 10.99 $ 5.99 Save $ 5.00

Sold Out

Bright Stripes & Trees Baking/Treat Cups - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Bright Stripes & Trees Baking/Treat Cups - My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Bright Stripes & Trees Baking/Treat Cups

Sale

Kraft Thankful/Grateful Baking/Treat Cups

$ 10.99 $ 5.99 Save $ 5.00

Nordic Snowflakes Loaf Pan Set

Christmas Holly Loaf Pan Set

Transportation Loaf Pan Set

Snowmen Loaf Pan Set

Let it Snow Loaf Pan Set

Candy Cane Bows Loaf Pan Set

Foil Christmas Icons Loaf Pan Set

Foil Christmas Icons on Pink Loaf Pan Set

After St. Patrick's Day Sale

Lucky you! For a limited time, take 50% off any St. Patrick’s Day item, even items already on sale. This deal won’t last long, so shop now before it’s gone.

50% Off With Code LUCKY50

Classic Easter On Sale

Classic Easter favorites—now at 25% off. From elegant tableware to charming décor, these timeless pieces won’t last long. Shop before they’re gone!

EASTER DECOR ON SALE

SIGNATURE EASTER 2025

Our new Signature Easter line is here! Featuring elegant designs, festive décor, and charming details, this collection is perfect for celebrating in style. We're so excited, this is our cutest Easter ever!

NEW 2025 EASTER & SPRING

50% Baking - Festive Baking Cups & Treat Cups | My Mind's Eye