Skip to content
  • Halloween 2025
    • 2025 ALL NEW HALLOWEEN ITEMS
    • PAST FALL FAVES BUY 5 GET 25% OFF
    • 2025 Theme: Vintage Halloween
    • 2025 Theme: Halloween Decor
    • 2025 Theme: Good Witch Bad Witch
    • 2025 Theme: Haunted Village Light-up Houses
    • 2025 Theme: Happy Halloween
    • 2025 Theme: Tricks & Treats
    • 2025 Theme: Boo to You!
    • 2025 Theme: Hey Boo
    • 2025 Theme: Boo La La
    • 2025 Theme: Spooky Spiders
    • 2025 Theme: Falloween
    • 2025 Theme: Groovy Pumpkin
    • 2025 Theme: Apothecary
  • Back To School
  • NEW & TRENDING
    • Halloween 2025
    • Fall Faves Buy 5 Get 25% Off
    • Football is Back!
    • Back To School
    • Can't Wait Christmas
    • Bestselling Party Supplies
  • HOLIDAYS
    • SEE ALL THEMES
    • Halloween
    • Thanksgiving | Harvest
    • Christmas
    • New Year's Eve
    • Hanukkah
    • Lunar New Year
    • Mardi Gras
    • Valentine's Day
    • St. Patrick's Day
    • Easter
    • Cinco De Mayo
    • Mother's Day
    • Father's Day
    • Graduation
    • Memorial Day
    • Fourth of July
    • Back To School
  • BIRTHDAYS
    • SEE ALL THEMES
    • Bright Birthday
    • Pet Birthday Party
    • Blast Off Birthday
    • Mermaid Party - Under the Sea
    • Howdy Partner Birthday
    • Safari Animal Birthday
    • Adventure Awaits Birthday
    • Pink CowGal Birthday
    • Big Top Carnival Party
    • Pretty Princess Party
    • A Wizards Dream - Spellbound
    • Pembroke English Party
    • Cake By Courtney & Accessories
    • SEE ALL SPORTS THEMES
    • SEE EVERY BIRTHDAY THEME
  • MILESTONES
    • SEE ALL THEMES
    • Baby's Day
    • Signature Birthdays
    • Back To School
    • Graduation
    • Bachelorette - Bride to Be
    • Wedding
  • PAPER PARTY SUPPLIES
    • SEE TRENDING ITEMS
    • Plates
    • Napkins
    • Banners
    • Fans
    • Table Runners
    • To-Go Cups
    • Baking Cups
    • Trays and Platters
    • Mylar Balloons
    • Treat Boxes
  • CLEARANCE
  • Log in
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
Cart
Learn More
Almost there, add $100.00 more to get FREE SHIPPING!
Subtotal
$ 0.00
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.
Your cart is currently empty.
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
Search
My Mind's Eye Paper Goods My Mind's Eye Paper Goods
Log in Search Cart
  • Halloween 2025
    • 2025 ALL NEW HALLOWEEN ITEMS
    • PAST FALL FAVES BUY 5 GET 25% OFF
    • 2025 Theme: Vintage Halloween
    • 2025 Theme: Halloween Decor
    • 2025 Theme: Good Witch Bad Witch
    • 2025 Theme: Haunted Village Light-up Houses
    • 2025 Theme: Happy Halloween
    • 2025 Theme: Tricks & Treats
    • 2025 Theme: Boo to You!
    • 2025 Theme: Hey Boo
    • 2025 Theme: Boo La La
    • 2025 Theme: Spooky Spiders
    • 2025 Theme: Falloween
    • 2025 Theme: Groovy Pumpkin
    • 2025 Theme: Apothecary
  • Back To School
  • NEW & TRENDING
    • Halloween 2025
    • Fall Faves Buy 5 Get 25% Off
    • Football is Back!
    • Back To School
    • Can't Wait Christmas
    • Bestselling Party Supplies
  • HOLIDAYS
    • SEE ALL THEMES
    • Halloween
    • Thanksgiving | Harvest
    • Christmas
    • New Year's Eve
    • Hanukkah
    • Lunar New Year
    • Mardi Gras
    • Valentine's Day
    • St. Patrick's Day
    • Easter
    • Cinco De Mayo
    • Mother's Day
    • Father's Day
    • Graduation
    • Memorial Day
    • Fourth of July
    • Back To School
  • BIRTHDAYS
    • SEE ALL THEMES
    • Bright Birthday
    • Pet Birthday Party
    • Blast Off Birthday
    • Mermaid Party - Under the Sea
    • Howdy Partner Birthday
    • Safari Animal Birthday
    • Adventure Awaits Birthday
    • Pink CowGal Birthday
    • Big Top Carnival Party
    • Pretty Princess Party
    • A Wizards Dream - Spellbound
    • Pembroke English Party
    • Cake By Courtney & Accessories
    • SEE ALL SPORTS THEMES
    • SEE EVERY BIRTHDAY THEME
  • MILESTONES
    • SEE ALL THEMES
    • Baby's Day
    • Signature Birthdays
    • Back To School
    • Graduation
    • Bachelorette - Bride to Be
    • Wedding
  • PAPER PARTY SUPPLIES
    • SEE TRENDING ITEMS
    • Plates
    • Napkins
    • Banners
    • Fans
    • Table Runners
    • To-Go Cups
    • Baking Cups
    • Trays and Platters
    • Mylar Balloons
    • Treat Boxes
  • CLEARANCE

Baking and treat cups

FANCY GOLD FOILED BAKING CUPS
Floral Baking Cups
Seasonal/Holiday baking cups
Coffee cups with lids in various designs
Bestselling Theme

Step into the charm of Halloweens past with our expanded Vintage Collection for 2025. Featuring nostalgic jack-o’-lanterns, rich velvets, and bold new banners in classic hues, this cozy, old-school line brings haunting elegance to your space.

SHOP Vintage Halloween
Popular Restock!

Let's Go! Celebrate with our Football Field Plates, #1 Hand Napkins, Bestselling Field Tray and Field Table Runner for a winning party. Beautifully neutral so you can add your team colors if desired. Football is finally back!

SHOP LET'S GO FOOTBALL
Going Fast

Elevate your Halloween decor with our faux wicker witch hat! This statement piece brings rustic elegance to your spooky celebrations. Perfect for mantels, entryways, or as a table centerpiece. Get ready to cast a stylish spell on your Halloween gathering!

Shop Wicker Hats

ABOUT/CONTACT

  • About My Mind's Eye
  • Customer Care & Support
  • Shipping Q & A
  • Privacy | Terms | Policies
  • Would you like to work with us?

Follow us on INSTAGRAM

CLICK HERE

MME CUSTOMER CARE & SUPPORT

CLICK HERE

WHOLESALE SIGN UP INFORMATION

CLICK HERE

PARTY BY EMAIL

What surprises await? 🧐 Get exclusive deals, secret offers, and insider perks—only in our weekly newsletter. Subscribe now! 🚀

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
  • Amazon
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Venmo
  • Visa

© 2025 My Mind's Eye Paper Goods

Baking & Treat cups by category

★ Reviews

Let customers speak for us

3111 reviews
Write a review
92%
(2861)
4%
(124)
2%
(61)
1%
(20)
1%
(45)
3111
A
Occasions Paper and Pencil Bamboo Tray Set
Alice Kuftedjian
Back to school platter

I purchased the ruler runner, pencil reusable straws and paper and pencil bamboo platter.. I cannot say how spectacular they were. The staff and guests still talk about the awesome decor. Mind’s Eye is my favorite and only party decor place.. also, when one of the platters arrived it was damaged and without any hesitation they replaced it.. Super customer service and very cute original products.. I love this place!!

A
Halloween Hanging Characters
Arlene Mazurek
Adorable

These Halloween characters are so adorable…they are a substantial size…easy to assemble and they look so cute hanging up!😍

W
Occasions By Shakira - Glue Bottle Plate
Wynita Harmon
Glue plates

These plates are perfect for anything school related. We used them for back to school! They were perfect

M
Light up Witch Hat set of 3
Mom of 4
Love!!!

These three hats are DARLING! I love mine. I was debating between these and the black wicker hats and I am very happy with my choice. Thank you My Minds Eye!

User picture
K
Occasions By Shakira - Globe Paper Plate
K.Coleman
Beautiful, Thoughtful, and High Quality

Love supporting a Black woman-created product can’t wait to order again! Bright, fun, and strong enough for all the treats. They brought the theme to life and made our setup extra special.

User picture
123